Sitemap
Return to Introduction
Thalassoma
Halichoeres
Xyrichtys
Doratonotus
Clepticus
Decodon
Bodianus
Lachnolaimus
The wrasses are a particularly abundant and diverse group of fishes found on reefs and grassbeds in the Caribbean, essentially occupying all shallow-water habitats. The bluehead wrasse, Thalassoma bifasciatum, is the single local representative of a widespread labrid genus and is ubiquitous on Caribbean reefs. Another prominent labrid genus, Halichoeres spp., has a large number of species and many regional representatives. However, the validity of unifying all of these species into a single genus is in question since phylogenetic studies clearly indicate the presence of three distinct clades among the Caribbean species. There are three local razorfishes, Xyrichtys spp., and two hogfishes, Bodianus spp. The remaining labrid genera are mostly monotypic: Doratonotus megalepis, Lachnolaimus maximus, Clepticus parrae, and the deep-water wrasse Decodon puellaris (the latter two species are monotypic only in the region, with sibling species elsewhere in the Atlantic or in the eastern Pacific).

Labrid larvae can be recognized by their long and continuous dorsal and anal fins with relatively flexible spines, a wide caudal peduncle, the absence of spines on the head, stub-like pelvic fins, a pointed snout with a small terminal mouth and typically light markings (none or melanophores mostly on the fin ray membranes). Melanophores are not present in a row on or near the anal fin base (separating labrid larvae from larval scarids, labrisomids, chaenopsids, dactyloscopids, and gobies). While most labrid larvae fit this general pattern of small and mostly unpigmented larvae, two genera have markedly divergent early life histories: larval Lachnolaimus maximus are fully-pigmented and Decodon melasma have an unusual and large late larval stage with a pattern of melanophore bars on the body.

  
Pre-transitional labrid larvae can have a variety of unusual eye morphologies: many larval Halichoeres spp. and Thalassoma bifasciatum have eyes that are narrowed vertical ovals, usually tilted backwards, but sometimes forwards. Larval Xyrichtys spp. have markedly-narrowed vertically oval eyes. Other larval labrids, such as Doratonotus megalepis, have round eyes throughout development. These eye shapes no doubt reflect differing life styles of these early life history stages in the pelagic realm.
While genera are relatively easily distinguished, conspecific larvae can appear similar, if not identical. Several species of Halichoeres spp. share melanophore patterns and only become recognizable to species during transition. Larval razorfishes, Xyrichtys spp., have no melanophores and do not diverge in appearance until juvenile markings develop (however their evanescent chromatophore patterns may be species-specific). Some Caribbean labrid larvae clearly require DNA sequence analyses for species identification.
Species are presented in order of dorsal spine count: from 8 to 14 in the regional labrids. Fin ray counts generally separate the Caribbean genera well.
Thalassoma bifasciatum
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-VIII,13 A-III,11 indicates Thalassoma bifasciatum.
Analogues: Larval Thalassoma spp. show distinctive melanophore edging along the median fins, although these melanophores can be absent in earlier stages and where the fins are frayed. This larval character is apparently unique to this genus, but may be shared to a limited degree by larvae of an unknown (new?) labrid genus collected from the eastern Pacific (type C in Victor 1987). In addition to the melanophore edging on the median fins, this larval type can be separated from larval Halichoeres spp. by having only a solitary patch of small melanophores on the anteriormost dorsal fin. Larval Bodianus rufus can appear similar but have a wider body, a larger round eye, and the dorsal fin origin is farther back on the body.
Description: Body relatively thin, narrow, and long with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. Melanophores limited to the fin ray membranes, in a group along the first two or three dorsal spines and then on the membrane fringes along the dorsal, anal, and caudal fins. Series of larvae show development of the eye from vertically oval to round (round in many larvae captured over the reef). Transitional recruits develop a prominent black spot on the front of the dorsal fin, a wide black stripe along the side from nose to tail and a dorsal stripe from the top of the head along the base of the dorsal fin. Transitional recruits on the reef commonly show remnants of the melanophores on the fin membrane edges characteristic of the larvae.
Thalassoma bifasciatum larva
11.3 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB81-051
 
 
Thalassoma bifasciatum larva
11.4 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB81-001
Notes on Halichoeres spp.
This large genus comprises eleven regional species, two of which have only recently been discovered: H. socialis from mangrove habitats in Belize (Randall and Lobel 2003) and H. bureki from deep reefs in the Gulf of Mexico. In addition, it appears that there may be cryptic species, at least within H. bivittatus. The phylogeny of the group is presently being revised and it is likely that it will be split into two or more genera. Most species share a basic fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,12 and Pect-13 (H. maculipinna and H. cyanocephalus, have slightly differing fin ray counts).
My mtDNA sequence analysis reveals that there is a single large clade of Halichoeres spp. consisting of H. bivittatus, H. cyanocephalus (and its Brazilian sibling H. dimidiatus), H. garnoti, H. poeyi, and H. radiatus. Then there is a smaller clade made up of H. pictus and H. socialis (along with the eastern Pacific H. dispilus and H. insularis). My results confirm that H. maculipinna falls out well away from the other Halichoeres spp. and nearer to Thalassoma spp. (Barber and Bellwood 2005). Three deeper-water species, H. bathyphilus, H. caudalis, and H. bureki, share the fin ray counts but were not examined in the phylogenetic studies.
The larvae of a number of Halichoeres spp. overlap in appearance and DNA sequencing is necessary to confirm the identity of larvae. The species do become distinct as they develop juvenile markings. The size at settlement for this genus is quite consistent, around 10-12 mm (interestingly, one eastern Pacific sibling, H. insularis, settles much larger, up to 22 mm SL). An unusual aspect of the early life history of these labrids is that larvae undergoing transition are not captured in pelagic sampling, but are found buried in sand and rubble on reefs. This attribute is shared with Thalassoma bifasciatum, but not with Doratonotus megalepis or the related parrotfishes, both of which begin transition while still pelagic and transitional larvae are commonly caught in nearshore collections.
Halichoeres bivittatus
 
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,12 and Pect-13 indicates Halichoeres spp. and is shared by most of the Caribbean species. Larval H. bivittatus are identical to other larval Halichoeres spp. with five patches of median fin melanophores and can only be identified by DNA sequencing.
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, narrow and long with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. Melanophores limited to the fin ray membranes between spines and rays, typically occurring in five groups: at the front, mid, and rear dorsal fin and the front and rear anal fin. Each melanophore group covers from one to five fin ray elements. Series of transitional larvae show development of the eye from vertically oval (and tilted backward) to round (round in many larvae captured over the reef). Transitional recruits on the reef commonly show remnants of the larval melanophores on the fin membranes. Transitional recruits of H. bivittatus on the reef have a mid-dorsal fin ocellus and a mid-lateral body stripe extending directly rearward from the eye, present even in the earliest transitional stages.
Halichoeres bivittatus larva
10.8 mm SL
DNA ID pending, few melanophores
San Blas, Panama, SB81-118
Halichoeres bivittatus? larva
11.9 mm SL
DNA ID pending, many melanophores
San Blas, Panama, SB81-023
Halichoeres bivittatus larva
10.3 mm SL
DNA ID pending, oval eye
San Blas, Panama, SB81-125
Halichoeres bivittatus larva
10.2 mm SL
DNA ID pending, typical slightly oval eye
San Blas, Panama, SB81-116
Halichoeres radiatus
 
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,12 and Pect-13 indicates Halichoeres spp. and is shared by most of the Caribbean species. Larval H. radiatus are identical to other larval Halichoeres spp. with five patches of median fin melanophores and can only be identified by DNA sequencing.
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, narrow and long with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. Transitional recruits on the reef have a mid-dorsal fin ocellus, a white-edged black spot on the upper base of the central caudal fin rays and a patchy pattern of melanophores along the body with a conspicuous mid-body bar extending from the dorsal ocellus down onto the anterior anal fin rays.
Halichoeres radiatus transitional recruit
11.9 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB82-018
Halichoeres garnoti
 
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,12 and Pect-13 indicates Halichoeres spp. and is shared by most of the Caribbean species. Larval H. garnoti are identical to other larval Halichoeres spp. with five patches of median fin melanophores and can only be identified by DNA sequencing.
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, narrow and long with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. Transitional recruits on the reef can show remnants of the larval melanophores on the fin membranes at the same five locations as are found in larval H. bivittatus. Transitional recruits of H. garnoti on the reef develop a mid-lateral body stripe from the lower half of the eye to the tail, extending onto the base of the caudal fin rays. There is no dorsal fin ocellus. The stripe is iridescent blue against a bright yellow body in life; in preserved specimens the stripe is underlain with fine melanophores.
Halichoeres garnoti transitional recruit
12.7 mm SL
larval melanophore remnants
San Blas, Panama, SB80-105
 
Halichoeres poeyi
 
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,12 and Pect-13 indicates Halichoeres spp. and is shared by most of the Caribbean species. Larvae with a total of four patches of melanophores on the dorsal and anal fins (missing the anterior patch of dorsal fin melanophores) represent H. poeyi (confirmed by DNA sequencing). Many larval H. poeyi have deep melanophores behind the braincase and along the dorsal peritoneum. Interestingly, larval Halichoeres spp. are virtually never caught in a transitional phase while pelagic, but can be found buried in sand or rubble on the reef. However, I did collect a single transitional larva of H. poeyi at a nightlight in Panama, and it was the largest individual Halichoeres spp. larvae out of many hundreds collected, i.e. 13.8 mm SL (this size range applies only to the Caribbean, larval Halichoeres spp. from the eastern Pacific and Indo-Pacific can reach more than 20 mm SL)
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, narrow, and long with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. Melanophores on the fin ray membranes between spines and rays, typically occurring in in four groups: at the mid and rear dorsal fin and the forward and rear anal fin. Each melanophore group covers from one to five fin ray elements. Most, but not all, larvae have a sub-surface melanophore at the top of the head behind the skull, sometimes two or three. Many of the larvae also have a small melanophore on the body at the ventral midline just after the last anal ray (often unnoticed adjacent to the large anal fin membrane melanophores). Unlike other larval Halichoeres spp., this species has internal melanophores along the dorsal peritoneal cavity. Series of transitional larvae show development of the eye from vertically oval (and tilted backward) to round with a large pupil (round in many larvae captured over the reef). The one transitional larva captured had begun to develop surface melanophores on the head. Transitional recruits on the reef commonly retain the larval melanophores behind the skull and remnants of the larval melanophores on the fin membranes. Transitional recruits of H. poeyi have a mid-dorsal fin ocellus, a spot on the caudal peduncle just behind the base of the last dorsal ray, a white-edged black spot on the upper base of the central caudal fin rays, a chain-link patch pattern along the lateral midline, and colored striping on the top of the head. Some variants lack the patch pattern and have melanophores uniformly covering the upper and lower sides of the body with a mid-lateral clear stripe with no melanophores.
Halichoeres poeyi larva
12.6 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB86-331
tr>
Halichoeres poeyi larva
12.5 mm SL
dorsal peritoneal melanophores
San Blas, Panama, SB80-102
Halichoeres poeyi transitional larva
13.8 mm SL
head melanophores
San Blas, Panama, SB80-102
 
Halichoeres poeyi early transitional recruit
11.1 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB83-137
Halichoeres poeyi early transitional recruit
11.6 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB83-148
Halichoeres pictus
 
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,12 and Pect-13 indicates Halichoeres spp. and is shared by most of the Caribbean species. In mtDNA sequence studies, H. pictus separates out from the large Caribbean Halichoeres spp. clade and is close to some eastern Pacific Halichoeres spp. that have distinctly larger larvae and a different fin melanophore pattern from other Halichoeres spp. Whether this is true for H. pictus awaits DNA sequence analyses underway at present.
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, narrow and long with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. Transitional recruits on the reef have a mid-dorsal fin ocellus, a white-edged black spot on the upper base of the central caudal fin rays and a patchy pattern of melanophores along the body with a conspicuous mid-body bar extending from the dorsal ocellus down onto the anterior anal fin rays.
Halichoeres radiatus transitional recruit
11.9 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB82-018
 
Halichoeres maculipinna
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,11 A-III,11 and Pect-14 indicates Halichoeres maculipinna. This species has a different fin ray count from the other Halichoeres spp. in the region and both larvae and recruits appear wider and thicker-bodied. In mtDNA sequence studies, H. maculipinna is distant from the rest of the genus. (U)
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, wide for labrids and long with a medium eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins very short. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and wide. Melanophores limited to the fin ray membranes between spines and rays, typically occurring on the last dorsal fin rays and a matching group on the last anal fin rays. Each melanophore group covers from three to five fin ray elements. Transitional recruits of H. maculipinna show much more variable juvenile markings than other labrids. Those individuals in grassbeds are uniformly green, while those on reefs have a distinct black stripe along the side of the body.
Halichoeres maculipinna larva
12.7 mm SL
Barbados, coll. by Henri Valles
Xyrichtys martinicensis
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,12 A-III,12 and Pect-12 indicates the razorfish genus Xyrichtys spp. One other regional labrid, Halichoeres cyanocephalus, shares the median fin ray count, but has 13 pectoral fin rays and a clearly different body shape. The three Caribbean razorfishes, X. martinicensis, X. novacula, and X. splendens, share fin ray counts and the larvae overlap in appearance. The species become distinct as they develop juvenile markings: X. martinicensis recruits are recognized by a simple lateral stripe from the eye to the tail that is not broken up into patches or spots.
Analogues: Larval Xyrichtys spp. have no melanophores and often markedly narrowed eyes. The absence of external melanophores is shared with larval Doratonotus megalepis, but the latter are distinctly wider-bodied and have large round eyes. All other regional labrid and scarid larvae have melanophore patterns through transition. X. martinicensis recruits have a simple lateral stripe from the eye to the tail while X. novacula recruits have a stripe that is broken up into discrete patches or spots. X. splendens recruits develop a complex pattern of bars and reticulations. X. martinicensis recruits also do not display the extended first dorsal fin spines characteristic of the juveniles of the other two razorfish species.
Description: Body thin and long with a markedly narrowed eye (pre-transitional) to large and round (recruits) with a pointed snout and a terminal small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins stubs. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. This larval type is notable for having no internal or external melanophores. Series of transitional larvae show development of the eye from vertically oval to round. Transitional recruits show a dark stripe of fine melanophores curving up from the eye across the upper body onto the base of the upper caudal fin segmented rays. There is a lighter band beneath the stripe ending in a whitish patch at the base of the central caudal fin rays.
Xyrichtys martinicensis recruit
13.0 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB82-098
Xyrichtys splendens
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,12 A-III,12 and Pect-12 indicates the razorfish genus Xyrichtys spp. One other regional labrid, Halichoeres cyanocephalus, shares the median fin ray count, but has 13 pectoral fin rays and a clearly different body shape. The three Caribbean razorfishes, X. martinicensis, X. novacula, and X. splendens, share fin ray counts and the larvae overlap in appearance. The species become distinct as they develop juvenile markings: X. splendens recruits are recognized by a pattern of bars and reticulations and the first two dorsal fin spines are extended. The extended dorsal fin spines persist until juveniles reach about 35 mm SL.
Analogues: Larval Xyrichtys spp. have no melanophores and often markedly narrowed eyes. The absence of external melanophores is shared with larval Doratonotus megalepis, but the latter are distinctly wider-bodied and have large round eyes. All other regional labrid and scarid larvae have melanophore patterns through transition. X. splendens recruits have a a complex pattern of bars and reticulations and the extended first two dorsal fin spines while X. martinicensis recruits have a lateral stripe from the eye to the tail and no extension of the dorsal fin spines and X. novacula recruits have a lateral stripe that is broken up into discrete patches or spots.
Description: Body thin and long with a markedly narrowed eye (pre-transitional) to large and round (recruits) with a pointed snout and a terminal small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins stubs. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. This larval type is notable for having no internal or external melanophores. Series of transitional larvae show development of the eye from vertically oval to round. Transitional recruits show a pattern of bars and reticulations and the first two dorsal fin spines are extended.
Xyrichtys martinicensis recruit
13.0 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB82-098
 
Xyrichtys novacula
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,12 A-III,12 and Pect-12 indicates the razorfish genus Xyrichtys spp. One other regional labrid, Halichoeres cyanocephalus, shares the median fin ray count, but has 13 pectoral fin rays and a clearly different body shape. The three Caribbean razorfishes, X. martinicensis, X. novacula, and X. splendens, share fin ray counts and the larvae overlap in appearance. The species become distinct as they develop juvenile markings: X. novacula recruits are recognized by lateral stripe broken up into patches or spots and the first two dorsal fin spines are extended. The extended dorsal fin spines persist until juveniles reach about 25 mm SL.
Analogues: Larval Xyrichtys spp. have no melanophores and often markedly narrowed eyes. The absence of external melanophores is shared with larval Doratonotus megalepis, but the latter are distinctly wider-bodied and have large round eyes. All other regional labrid and scarid larvae have melanophore patterns through transition. X. novacula recruits have a lateral stripe broken up into patches or spots and the first two dorsal fin spines are extended while X. martinicensis recruits have an intact stripe and no extended first dorsal fin spines. X. splendens recruits develop a complex pattern of bars and reticulations.
Description: Description: Body thin and long with a markedly narrowed eye (pre-transitional) to large and round (recruits) with a pointed snout and a terminal small mouth. Pectoral fins medium, reach to vent. Pelvic fins stubs. Dorsal and anal fin bases long, caudal peduncle short and relatively wide. This larval type is notable for having no internal or external melanophores. Series of transitional larvae show development of the eye from vertically oval to round. Transitional recruits show a lateral stripe broken up into patches or spots and the first two dorsal fin spines are extended.
Xyrichtys martinicensis recruit
13.0 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB82-098
 
Doratonotus megalepis
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-IX,10 A-III,9 with only 11 or 12 pectoral fin rays indicates Doratonotus megalepis. Caribbean parrotfishes (family Scaridae) share the median fin ray count, but have 13-16 pectoral fin rays. (U)
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, short and wide with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral and pelvic fins short. Dorsal and anal fin bases relatively long, caudal peduncle short and wide. The only melanophores are internal on the dorsal peritoneal cavity, usually one or two. Series of transitional larvae show development of the eye from flat and round with a large pupil to somewhat bulbous with a small pupil. Transitional larvae develop bars of tiny melanophores radiating out from the eye as well as a broad iridophore bar from the eye across the lower operculum. Small melanophores develop on the first dorsal spines and the base of the pelvic rays.
Doratonotus megalepis larva
6.9 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB86-413
Doratonotus megalepis larva
7.0 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB86-415
Doratonotus megalepis larvae
6.6, 6.7, and 6.8 mm SL
variation in # of internal melanophores
San Blas, Panama, SB84-523
Doratonotus megalepis transitional larva
6.2 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB84-520
 
 
Doratonotus megalepis transitional larva
6.2 mm SL
eye changes with small pupil
San Blas, Panama, SB86-413
Decodon puellaris
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-XI,10 A-III,10 indicates Decodon puellaris. I have not identified larvae of D. puellaris in my collections, but larvae corresponding to the eastern Pacific sibling species, D. melasma, share the fin ray count and are likely similar. The distinctive eastern Pacific larvae are identified by their unique fin ray count as well as a mtDNA sequence that falls within the labrids and near to both Clepticus spp. and Bodianus spp. (U)
Analogues:
Description:
Clepticus parrae
 
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-XII,10 A-III,12 and Pect-17 indicates Clepticus parrae. Bodianus spp. share the median fin ray count, but have one less pectoral fin ray (and a different body shape). (U)
Analogues:
Description:
 
 
Bodianus rufus
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-XII,10 A-III,12 and Pect-16 indicates Bodianus spp. Clepticus parrae shares the median fin ray count but has one more pectoral fin ray (and a different body shape). The two Caribbean Bodianus spp. share their fin ray counts, but B. rufus is far more common than the deep-water species B. pulchellus (although the latter cannot be excluded for the pre-transitional larval stages). B. rufus larvae develop into a bicolored recruit with the anterior lower half dark blue and the rear and upper half yellow (in contrast to adults where it is often the opposite pattern). Recruits of B. pulchellus are uniformly yellow. (U)
Analogues:
Description: Body relatively thin, long and wide with a large eye and a terminal, pointed, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral fins medium length. Pelvic fins short. Dorsal and anal fin bases relatively long, caudal peduncle short and wide.
Bodianus rufus recruit
10.1 mm SL
San Blas, Panama, SB81-077
 
Lachnolaimus maximus
Diagnosis: The fin ray count of D-XIV,11 A-III,10 indicates Lachnolaimus maximus. I have not collected this species, but Colin (1982) raised the larvae through their larval phase. The larvae resemble Doratonotus megalepis in basic form, but develop surface melanophores early in development, around the time the fin rays are fully formed (about 5 mm SL). This feature is particularly unusual for labrids (or other labroids) and it is likely that this species is the sole member of the family to have body pigmentation (none of the Indo-Pacific labroid larvae identified by Leis and Carson-Ewart (2000) have this character). The adaptation suggests that larval L. maximus are associated with drift algae and not exposed in the plankton.
Analogues: In most features this larval type resembles larval Doratonotus megalepis, but it is distinguished by a slightly different fin ray count and, most conspicuously, by having extensive melanophore patterns on the body. The arrangement of melanophores on the head resembles that of transitional D. megalepis and they share the markings on the first dorsal spines and pelvic fins, but even late transitional D. megalepis do not have the reticulated patterns on the body.
Description: Body relatively thin, short and wide with a large eye and a terminal, somewhat small mouth. Pectoral and pelvic fins short. Dorsal and anal fin bases relatively long, caudal peduncle short and wide. By the time the fin ray complement has formed, around 5.5 mm SL, melanophores are scattered over the body and in three discrete patches along the anal fin base. Subsequently, melanophores develop in bars radiating from the eye: forward across the jaw, a vertical below the eye, and in bands across the top of the head. A reticulated pattern of melanophores then develops over the body. Since the larvae were raised in captivity, the point of transition cannot be determined. Series of larvae shows the eye remains round.
All contents © copyright 2006 Benjamin Victor. All rights reserved.